Quick Answer: Putting $50,000 against a $350,000 balance at 6% with 25 years left cuts the payment from $2,255.05 to $1,932.90 -- a saving of $322.15 a month, with the same rate and the same term. But if you can keep paying the old amount instead, not recasting saves $85,167.71 more in interest and clears the loan 6.7 years early.
Overview
A recast re-amortises your existing loan after a lump sum principal payment. The rate stays, the term stays, and the payment falls. There is no new loan, no underwriting and no closing costs, just a fee of a few hundred dollars.
That makes it very different from a refinance, and especially valuable for anyone holding a legacy low rate they do not want to give up.
The decision that actually matters is not recast versus refinance, but recast versus prepay without recasting. The same $50,000 can either:
- Recast, lowering the payment to $1,932.90 and freeing $322.15 a month, or
- Prepay and keep paying $2,255.05, which retires the loan 6.7 years early and saves $85,167.71 more in interest
Both use the same money. They buy different things: one buys monthly cash flow, the other buys total interest saved.
How This Is Calculated
New balance is the current balance less the lump sum.
The recast payment re-amortises that smaller balance over the unchanged remaining term at the unchanged rate:
Because the rate and term are unchanged, the payment falls in exact proportion to the balance. Reducing a balance by 14.3% reduces the payment by 14.3%.
Prepaying without recasting keeps the original payment on the smaller balance, so the term shortens. The engine solves for the number of periods and derives total interest from there.
Worked Example
$350,000 at 6%, 25 years remaining, $50,000 lump sum:
- New balance: $300,000
- Payment falls from $2,255.05 to $1,932.90, a saving of $322.15 a month
- Total interest if you do nothing: $326,515
- Total interest if you recast: $279,870
- Total interest if you prepay and keep paying the old amount: $194,702.29
- Not recasting saves a further $85,167.71 and cuts 6.7 years off the loan
A $10,000 lump sum: the payment falls to $2,190.62, a saving of $64.43 a month. This is around the minimum most lenders will recast.
A $150,000 lump sum: the payment falls to $1,288.60, a reduction of 43%, while keeping the original rate.
On a legacy 3% rate: the advantage of not recasting narrows to $27,117.86, because there is far less interest to save. At low rates, taking the cash flow is a more reasonable choice.
What This Does Not Account For
- The recast fee, typically $150 to $500, and lender minimums for the lump sum.
- Whether your loan is eligible. FHA, VA and USDA loans generally cannot be recast. Most conventional loans can, but jumbo terms vary.
- The opportunity cost of the lump sum. Paying down a 3% mortgage while a savings account pays 4.5% is a losing trade before tax.
- Tax deductibility. Reducing deductible mortgage interest has an after-tax cost for itemisers.
- Escrow. Taxes and insurance are unchanged by a recast, so your total monthly outgoing falls by less than the principal-and-interest saving shown here.
- Emergency liquidity. Money paid into a mortgage is very hard to get back out without borrowing again.
- PMI. A large lump sum may push you below 80% LTV and allow cancellation, which is a separate saving not modelled here.
- Whether you will actually keep paying the higher amount. The prepay-without-recast advantage depends entirely on discipline.
Common Pitfalls
- Confusing a recast with a refinance. A refinance replaces the loan, changes the rate and costs thousands. A recast keeps everything and costs a few hundred.
- Recasting when you wanted interest savings. Recasting is the worse option on total interest, by $85,168 here. It is the better option only if you need the monthly cash flow.
- Prepaying a cheap legacy mortgage at all. At 3%, with savings accounts paying more, the lump sum may be better off invested. The calculator shows the mortgage side only.
- Assuming your loan qualifies. Government-backed loans generally cannot be recast, and lenders set their own minimums.
- Forgetting escrow. The payment shown is principal and interest. Taxes and insurance continue unchanged.
- Draining the emergency fund. A recast lowers the payment but the money is gone. Liquidity has value that this calculation cannot show.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a mortgage recast?
Recast or refinance?
Should I recast or just prepay?
Which loans can be recast?
Does recasting hurt my credit?
Should I pay down a 3% mortgage at all?
Sources
- Standard loan amortisation mathematics. The recast payment is the ordinary annuity payment on the reduced balance over the unchanged remaining term.
- The prepay-without-recast comparison solves for the number of periods at the unchanged payment, which is the standard treatment.